
The names in this story have been changed for the subjects’ privacy, immigration status, and the stigma sometimes associated with sex work.
Paul, a 60-something executive for a charitable organization in California, and Roberto, a performer on Chaturbate, met during the COVID-era lockdown, when idle hands had people looking for connection in isolation.
Related
I ask Paul, “What was your goal in contacting Roberto?”
“Making friends. I was bored.”
Never Miss a Beat
Subscribe to our newsletter to stay ahead of the latest LGBTQ+ political news and insights.
Subscribe to our Newsletter today
“It was a pandemic,” he says.
Paul had scrolled through the seemingly endless collection of performers in the men’s section on the site and landed on Roberto, a handsome “masc” type in his early 30s from Medellin in Colombia.
After a few tips, Paul private-messaged him and shared his WhatsApp.
“We chatted mostly offline after that,” he says.
“What did you guys talk about?”
“His life, my life, his goals. Yeah.”
“And what were some of his goals?”
“Well, he had a five-year-old son to support, whose mother died, I think, a couple months after he was born. He did not tell me his goal was to come to the U.S. That was a surprise later. He just wanted to earn money to support his son.”
Fast forward about a year later: Paul was in Medellin with his husband, visiting friends. He’d spent time with Roberto there a couple of times before, when he’d seen clues to Colombia’s status as Chaturbate’s biggest content provider.

“The first time I visited Colombia, it was towards the end of the pandemic,” Paul told me. “There were still ‘ Help Wanted ‘ signs on the street from the studios. ‘Be a model. Call this number.’”
A look at the male performers on Chaturbate reveals at least half with a Colombian flag marking their nationality, from Bogatá, Medellin, and Cali, among other location descriptors like “In your dreams” and “Pleasure City.”
Some of the performers are solo entrepreneurs working with a camera out of their apartments, but most work for studios like Roberto did, many in warehouses with cubicles lined up one after another like a sex-work Hollywood dream factory, if Hollywood stars had pink Lovense vibrators activated by their fans with tips.
Another of Paul’s friends, Ramon, worked for a studio that he described as generous.
“He made more there than at his real job,” Paul says. “That studio seemed to treat people very well. They had outings and bonuses and all kinds of stuff, gifts.”
“What else can you tell me about Ramon?” I ask.
“Well, he’s college-educated. He went to seminary and was sexually assaulted by the priest in charge, left seminary, started working, but then the pandemic came and he lost his work. So he only did it because of the pandemic,” Paul replied.
“Did he identify as gay?”
Unlike Roberto, he did.
“That’s a fascinating intersection with the Catholic Church,” I say.
“That intersection, yes, that’s interesting. But again, with him, it was out of — I don’t want to say desperation — but it was the only thing to do at that time.”
“They get 60 to 70% of what Chaturbate sends the studio,” Paul said of performers on the site. “So probably less than half of what the customer spends.”
It’s not enough to make a living if you’re anything but a star performer, and it’s one reason that Paul goes offline to chat with those he’s formed a connection with.
“If I send them 25 bucks [directly], they get a lot more of it than if I give them $25 worth of tips [through Chaturbate,” he says.
It was on that trip that Paul learned about Roberto’s desire to come to the US, though Roberto wasn’t around to explain it in person.
“He messaged me and said he was in Tijuana, starving,” Paul says. “He wanted some pizza. He was sitting in a motel room with 30 other guys.”
Roberto had taken his Chaturbate earnings and paid a coyote to get him to the US.
“And I said, ‘Well, I’m not going to buy pizza for you if there’s 30 other guys there.’ So I sent enough for all of them to eat.”

“I’m known for being charitable,” Paul says.
He traces that quality, along with his lifetime of political activism, to his religious upbringing in a suburb in Northern California.
“I’m a Lutheran. We’re the ones who gave ICE hell while they were in Minneapolis,” he says. “Lutherans got involved in immigration in the US right after World War II to help Europeans, and that work continues now with all countries with refugees.”
Paul’s most recent effort on that account was with Border Servant Corps, a faith-based humanitarian group that helps reunite families in the US-Mexico borderlands.
“I’ve done two trips with them. They hosted immigrants who were coming across El Paso, and they housed them, fed them, gave them medical care, and then sent them on to their families. After Trump came in, they’re basically closed because there are no clients,” he adds. “There’s no more immigrants.”
Roberto’s trip to Tijuana was in a different time, when refugees from all over Latin America took the change in American administrations as an invitation to seek asylum in the US.
One who lingered for years trying to cross in the same spot was Paul’s friend, Angel.
“Matt and I met him when we visited Tijuana. He is from Honduras, and he lived in Tijuana for, I think, seven years before he crossed. He is really gay, and he has pictures of him having been beaten up for being gay. And he was sexually assaulted in Honduras, so his story is more painful, but he crossed in the desert with a coyote a couple times before it finally took.”
“How did you meet Angel?”
“Grindr. Yeah, and we became friends. After that, it wasn’t sexual. It was funny, though, because he used a different name in Mexico in order to work, so I had him in my phone as ‘Orlando Vers’ for years before I learned his real name.”

Paul’s dalliance with Roberto happened in Miami.
His pizza delivery for the group holed up in that motel room inspired Roberto’s friendship with another Colombian, Javier. The Cali native had family in Miami, and he invited Roberto to join him there after both men were admitted to the US under Biden-era rules granting them temporary asylum as their claims were processed.
The two had learned about the Biden administration’s Customs and Border Patrol app on their run through Mexico, and booked a pre-screening appointment online.
“Then they climbed the wall and immediately sought out CBP and asked for asylum,” Paul recounts.
Paul and Matt flew to Florida to welcome Roberto and Javier for what turned out to be the Colombians’ short stay in the Sunshine State.
“They spent two days having fun with us, and then they got kicked out of the house they were staying at. I think their landlord got mad that they weren’t looking for work. That’s my guess,” Paul says. “My Spanish wasn’t as good then.”
“When you say ‘having fun,’ are you having sex with these guys?” I ask.
“That wasn’t the purpose. We went to the beach and went out to lunch. That was the only time we had sex.”
I asked if that’s what he came to Miami expecting.
“Was that part of an arrangement to help support them?”
“The sex? No. I think they thought that’s what I wanted. They thought that was my motivation. Yes.”

“I like a full house,” Paul says, by way of explaining how he’s ended up hosting refugees or new arrivals or just people in need over the years in his home in a rural part of Northern California. They’ve been gay and straight, men and women, and almost all anxious to make a success of their lives in the US.
That was the case for Roberto and Javier.
After Miami, “I got them plane tickets to come stay with me,” Paul says.
But the obstacles to success in the US don’t end at the border, or even under a supportive roof like Paul’s.
“Their motivation was always finding work, but it is the nature of our country that the most frequent abusers of recent immigrants are the immigrants who came less recently. The Latino community generally helps the Latino community, but often abuses it. So that’s what was going on. They’d beat out other Latinos, find work, and then sometimes it would work out, sometimes it wouldn’t.”
Javier tried his luck elsewhere.
“He went to stay with a distant cousin in Texas, and it was just really abusive. So Javier came back,” Paul recounts.
Part of Paul’s support was finding Roberto and Javier a law firm to guide them through the immigration process.
“Their lawyers were very pleased with Roberto’s Chaturbate experience, to show coercion into the sex trade. I think that’s not the term they used, but that’s what I gathered. The lawyers said it would be very helpful.”
“What do you know about coercion?”
“It wasn’t coercion. It was a way to make money.”
“Did that have to do with a gay asylum claim specifically?” I ask.
“It sounded like it, but again, I wasn’t in on that conversation.”

One myth Paul was anxious to bust was about asylum seekers coming to the US just to collect government benefits.
“I could not get Roberto and Javier to plug into resources,” Paul says. “They never applied for social services, or applied and never followed through. They were so work-focused that that wasn’t on their list of things to do. They’re all work-focused. The idea that they’re here to get benefits is just ridiculous.”
“Do you think they worried that they’d be exposed to more scrutiny if they got into the system?” I ask.
“They had status. That’s what the lawyer told them.”
Exactly what constitutes legal status, of course, has been thrown into question with the Trump administration’s immigration crackdown, which seems aimed in large part on anyone who arrived in the country on Joe Biden’s watch.
Javier decided to return to Colombia soon after Trump returned to the White House.
“Javier is back with his family and his son,” Paul shares.
Others have had more success with Paul’s support in the US, including Angel from Honduras. After “Orlando Vers” made it across the border on his second coyote attempt, Paul picked him up in Los Angeles and drove him north to his place.
“He was so work-focused that he only stayed a couple days, went to another town nearby, and has been working ever since. And now he has the legal status,” Paul says.
But Paul may be most proud of Roberto, who is thriving in a beach town south of San Francisco and supporting his young son, who’s living with family in Colombia; he’s the reason Paul met Roberto on Chaturbate in the first place.
“He plugged in with different Latino communities and got work for a while, and recently got hired by his town. He has permission to work, and he’s awaiting his hearing,” Paul notes.
There are still hurdles that Roberto and anyone else new to the country are facing. In California, rumors flew last month that ICE was launching a new offensive in the central part of the state.
“I know that Roberto’s work got shut down last week,” Paul says. “Even though he has legal status, they shut down the work.”
I ask Paul if he considers himself a mentor or a father figure to the people like Roberto he helps.
“Yeah. These guys all have terrible fathers.”
“Roberto is from his father’s second family. Did you see Evita? Remember how her father had a real family and then a second family? It goes on a lot. Sometimes there’s a third and fourth family out there, too,” Paul says.
“But the main family unit for all those people is the mother and the children she has. And because they’re Catholic, they are devoted to their mothers, and there will be no divorce. Roberto is close with his father’s other children, but not with his father.”
“Are you talking to Roberto regularly?” I ask.
“We talk every day.”
Subscribe to the LGBTQ Nation newsletter and be the first to know about the latest headlines shaping LGBTQ+ communities worldwide.