
The rats are fleeing the sinking ship, but they’re still rats.
The midterms were a massive repudiation of the MAGA movement. After six years of Donald Trump, the shine is off the apple, and Democrats have made generational gains in the House, Senate, governorships, state legislatures, and more. It’s hard to see any way forward for MAGA after this.
Related
Trump is promising to become “Mr Veto” now that Democrats won Congress. He’s that big a failure.
The movement must surely be dead in the water. But that doesn’t mean the ideology behind it is dead. It’s going to search for a new host instead, just as it has done before.
Key MAGA-aligned Republicans have already lost the power of office. Marjorie Taylor Greene resigned last year, Nancy Mace’s campaign for South Carolina governor failed in the primaries, and now Lauren Boebert has lost her House seat. With the Blue Wave washing in, the writing has been on the wall for plenty of non-elected groups who were once happy to cozy up to Trump and the MAGA bandwagon, and they have moved to distance themselves already.
Dive deeper every day
Join our newsletter for thought-provoking commentary that goes beyond the surface of LGBTQ+ issues
Subscribe to our Newsletter today
Elon Musk has been brazen in his attempts to distance himself from the MAGA brand. Musk was a vocal supporter of Trump’s second term, donated heavily to the campaign, ran DOGE, and then had his America PAC spend over $100 million on AI-generated anti-trans to support MAGA and Republican candidates in the midterms.
“I’m not MAGA,” Musk claimed in an interview with The New York Times. “If that means sort of a blind adherence to a set of policies by the Republican Party, then I certainly don’t have that.” It’s unclear what he thought about the black “Make America Great Again” hat he wore around the campaign and then in the White House.
Musk’s “new phone, who dis?” comments are laughable, and his assertion that he supports moderate politics doesn’t gel with the last two years, when he spent a chunk of time taking a chainsaw to the government. And yet, more concerning than his lies are the once-MAGA-aligned who are now looking to the future.
The Federalist Society has enjoyed a huge amount of power during Trump’s presidency, effectively telling Trump which judges he should install to help further their right-wing agenda. That has extended to shaping the Supreme Court for decades to come. Trump clearly took the group’s recommendations blindly, and in 2025 he blamed them for judges turning on his tariff plans. They’re now having conversations behind the scenes and at their conventions about what a post-MAGA world means for them, and clearly aren’t planning to go down with the ship.
At their annual convention for their lawyers in DC after the election, Leonard Leo, co-chair of the Federalist Society Board, said, “Historically, we’ve managed to put our chin up and just move on, knowing that what we do is a longer-term battle.”
That simple sentence reveals the truth of what we face with MAGA, Trump, and the anti-LGBTQ+ forces that support them. There’s no mistake that the MAGA movement and the Trump figurehead have given the anti-LGBTQ+ groups a tremendous amount of power while Republicans have been in control, and taking that power away through the House and Senate (and, presumably, in two years, the presidency) is a huge win that can make a real difference.
But those anti-LGBTQ+ forces are going to continue working in the background. National organizations like the Federalist Society, the Heritage Foundation, and the Alliance Defending Freedom (ADF) are among them. But there are also countless state-level groups like Protect Kids Colorado and Let’s Go Washington that helped to push anti-trans ballot initiatives in the midterms that are now doing real harm to trans kids.
The election swung heavily towards Democrats as Americans were tired of unnecessary war and not being able to afford their groceries and gas, but anti-trans ballot initiatives still passed even in blue states. That alone shows the power of the misinformation around trans people and the way that these pressures will continue to exist.
None of those national organizations were invented under Trump (although members of Trump’s administration, like Stephen Miller, have still founded new similar groups under his tenure). ADF was founded in 1993, the Federalist Society in 1982, and the Heritage Foundation was founded over 50 years ago.
Those groups, and others like them, have been behind movement conservatism and attacks on the LGBTQ+ community for decades, whether that’s under the heading of the GOP base, the Tea Party, or MAGA. They weren’t born with MAGA, and they won’t die with it either.
They may have some time over the next two years to figure out how to rebrand. When Trump leaves the White House, they’ll need to find a new figurehead for their movement. But those groups will still be in the background, pushing their hateful ideas while hiding behind the façade of a political party.
This might be the death of MAGA, and it could be the death of the Republican Party as we have known it in recent decades. But we can’t forget that those groups that push anti-LGBTQ+ hate will still be working hard, and we need to be watching where they are going so that we can be ready to fight back and prevent them from accruing the power that they once found under MAGA.
Subscribe to the LGBTQ Nation newsletter and be the first to know about the latest headlines shaping LGBTQ+ communities worldwide.